March 04, 2024

What Happens if I Ignore a Subrogation Letter or Lawsuit Papers?

subrogation word written on white paperWhen you receive a subrogation letter or are served with lawsuit papers, it signifies that an insurance company is seeking reimbursement for payments made on behalf of its insured(s) for damage it claims you caused. This letter is not just a simple request; it’s a formal notice that initiates a process which could have significant financial implications.

Ignoring a subrogation letter is ill-advised. The initial consequence might seem benign, merely an additional letter or reminder. However, the situation can quickly escalate. The insurance company or the subrogating party has a vested interest in recovering the funds, and they are equipped with legal resources to pursue this objective. Here’s a breakdown of the top 10 repercussions you could face:

No. 10: Credit Score Impact and Opportunities Lost

Judgments, liens, and aggressive collection activities orchestrated by an insurance subrogation law firm can have a devastating effect on your credit score. The repercussions include challenges in securing loans, navigating higher interest rates, and encountering barriers when attempting to rent apartments. The stain on your financial reputation can linger, affecting various aspects of your life and requiring significant time and effort to repair.

No. 9: Risk of Default Judgment

Ignoring communications from subrogation lawyers or the insurance company can culminate in a default judgment against you, without your participation in a trial. This outcome is particularly dire because it effectively treats the case as though it were heard and decided against you, carrying all the legal and financial penalties of a judgment following a full court hearing. This underscores the critical importance of engaging with the process, potentially with the assistance of a Texas subrogation lawyer, to avoid such unilateral decisions that can have long-term negative impacts on your financial and legal standing.

No. 8: Diminished Negotiation Leverage

Negotiation is a powerful tool in resolving disputes related to insurance claims. However, failing to respond to the initial claim from a subrogation law firm diminishes your leverage significantly. Without the initiative to engage, you lose the opportunity to potentially negotiate a more favorable settlement or payment plan. This can result in facing the full brunt of the initial claim without the chance to mitigate it, emphasizing the value of early and proactive engagement with a subrogation attorney in Texas.

No. 7: Missing Critical Deadlines

Failing to reply to a subrogation letter, and/or turn it over to your insurance carrier, risks missing crucial response deadlines, limiting future legal defenses. Prompt action, potentially with legal advice, is necessary to navigate these deadlines.

No. 6: Challenges in Future Defense

Ignoring the initial claim from a subrogation law firm not only weakens your current position but also complicates any future defense you might wish to mount if the case escalates to court. The delay in response results in lost time that could have been used to gather evidence, strategize a defense, and consult with subrogation lawyers.  Furthermore, your own insurance carrier may deny coverage due to your non-cooperation with them in letting them know of the claim.

No. 5: Judgment Against You

A court judgment against you becomes public, affecting loans, housing, and employment opportunities. The lasting public record emphasizes the broad implications of legal disputes.

No. 4: Lawsuit and Accumulating Legal Fees

Facing a lawsuit incurs substantial legal fees, regardless of the outcome. This financial burden underscores the cost of litigation and the value of seeking resolution or defense strategies early.

No. 3: Property Liens

A lien is a legal claim or hold on a property as security for a debt or obligation. Following a judgment in favor of the insurance company, insurance subrogation attorneys can file an Abstract of Judgment which causes liens to attach to all of your non-exempt assets. These liens can restrict your ability to sell or refinance property without first settling the subrogation claim. The imposition of a lien not only affects your current financial flexibility but also has long-term implications for your asset management and financial planning.

No. 2: Bank Account Levy

Following a court judgment, the insurance company, through its subrogation law firm, may receive authorization to seize funds directly from your bank accounts. This bank levy is a forceful action that immediately impacts your financial resources, possibly catching you unprepared for other financial obligations. The direct and immediate access to your financial assets underscores the severity of legal judgments and the importance of managing legal disputes proactively to avoid such drastic measures.

No. 1: The Suspension of Driver’s License and Registration Privileges

Texas law requires all drivers to have insurance while on the road.  As part of a judgment against you for causing an accident while driving uninsured: a) the court can order you to pay attorneys fees to a subrogating insurance carrier; b) the court can order you to reimburse a subrogating insurance carrier for Personal Injury Protection benefits it paid to its insured for injuries sustained in the accident; and, c) the Texas Department of Public Safety can suspend your driver’s license and vehicle registration privileges until you make arrangements to pay for the judgment.

Protect Your Rights and Privileges

If you receive a subrogation letter, turn it over to your insurance carrier immediately.  If you were not personally insured at the time of the accident but were driving someone else’s vehicle, ask them about their insurance carrier and then provide that carrier with the notice or suit papers.  If you were not insured at all, respond to the subrogation letter and/or suit papers and attempt to negotiate an agreement in order to retain your license and registration privileges.


Get to the Finish Line

Our firm’s commitment to professionalism, civility, and open and honest communication allows us to provide our clients with the highest level of professional service.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.